Picture this: A mentee arrives with a carefully prepared list of questions. The mentor, having reviewed their notes, offers polished solutions to each problem. Both leave feeling “productive.” Yet despite the exchange of valuable information, something essential was missing—the kind of connection that sparks genuine transformation.
If this scenario sounds familiar, you’re not alone. When mentorship becomes a checkbox item—something to highlight in development plans or company handbooks- it can take on a transactional rather than transformational nature.
What separates mentorship that truly transforms careers and lives from standard advice-giving relationships? The answer lies in what we call “authentic presence”—and it’s more accessible than you might think.
The Mentorship Opportunity: Why Good Intentions Fall Short
Traditional mentorship often operates like a knowledge vending machine: insert question, receive wisdom, repeat. While this transactional approach provides value, it barely scratches the surface of what’s possible when two people genuinely connect around growth and development.
The challenge isn’t a lack of expertise or good intentions. Instead, it’s that both mentors and mentees often get trapped in role-playing rather than relationship-building. Mentors feel pressure to project flawless wisdom. Mentees believe they must appear perpetually eager and competent. These projected images create barriers to the vulnerability necessary for breakthrough moments.
The most effective mentorship relationships are characterised not by a mentor’s expertise level, but by the quality of presence and connection both parties bring to their interactions.
What Is Authentic Presence?
Authentic presence is the foundation for transformative learning and development. It’s about engaging with another person beyond roles, assumptions, and the need to manage your professional image.
When both mentor and mentee bring authentic presence to their relationship, something remarkable happens: the interaction becomes a collaborative space for discovery that neither person could access alone. Instead of one-way knowledge transfer, you create conditions for mutual insight and growth.
This doesn’t mean abandoning professionalism or boundaries. Rather, it means showing up as a complete human being within an appropriate professional context—bringing curiosity instead of certainty, vulnerability alongside competence, and genuine interest in the other person’s unique journey.
The Four Stages of Developing Authentic Presence
Through research and observation of mentoring relationships across various industries, we’ve identified four distinct stages that mark the journey toward authentic presence:
Stage 1: Image Management
Most mentoring relationships begin here, and unfortunately, many never progress beyond it. Both parties focus primarily on fulfilling expected roles according to organisational or cultural scripts.
Mentors feel compelled to project expertise and provide immediate solutions. Mentees believe they must appear consistently motivated and quick to implement advice. While this creates predictable interactions, it limits the depth and transformative potential of the relationship.
What this looks like: Conversations follow predictable patterns, advice feels generic, and both parties leave feeling they’ve “done mentorship” without experiencing genuine connection or insight.
Stage 2: Becoming Aware of Your Patterns
The second stage involves developing awareness of the thoughts, assumptions, and expectations that shape your mentoring interactions. This includes noticing internal pressures about how you think you “should” behave in your role.
The key at this stage isn’t immediately changing these patterns—it’s simply noticing them. This awareness creates space between your automatic responses and your choices, allowing new possibilities to emerge.
What this looks like: You catch yourself mid-advice when you realise you’re speaking from a script rather than genuine insight. You notice when you’re managing your image instead of engaging authentically.
Stage 3: Developing Personal Presence
Personal presence involves bringing full attention to the actual experience unfolding in front of you, rather than operating from templates or preconceptions about how development “should” happen.
This embodied awareness provides real-time cues about what’s needed in the moment. Instead of relying on predetermined agendas, you become responsive to what’s emerging in the conversation.
Practical approaches for developing personal presence:
- Pre-session centring: Take 5-10 minutes before mentoring conversations to breathe deeply, clear mental clutter, and ground yourself in the present moment
- Reflective journaling: Regular writing practice helps you connect with your authentic thoughts and feelings, developing self-awareness that translates into relational awareness
- Mindfulness practices: Whatever form works for you—meditation, walking, contemplation—these practices strengthen your capacity to remain present under pressure
- Body awareness: Notice physical tension, breathing patterns, and energy levels as indicators of your internal state
Remember: your outer relationships reflect your inner state of being. To create open, authentic mentoring relationships, you must cultivate openness and authenticity within yourself.
Stage 4: Experiencing Inter-Relational Presence
The fourth stage represents shared presence between mentor and mentee. Here, both parties are fully engaged and creating insights together that neither could access individually.
This transcends traditional mentorship as one-way knowledge transfer. The relationship itself becomes a source of wisdom, revealing insights that surprise both parties and catalyse mutual growth.
What this looks like: Conversations become generative rather than just informative. Solutions emerge from the dialogue itself. Both people leave feeling energised and enriched by the interaction.
Real-World Application: A Case Study
Consider Sarah, a senior marketing director who had been mentoring professionals for eight years. She approached each session with carefully prepared insights and structured guidance. When her mentee Cleo brought up a complex organisational challenge she hadn’t encountered, her instinct was to shift into advice-giving mode despite having no direct experience with the situation.
In one pivotal session, something shifted. Instead of offering polished wisdom, Sarah simply said, “I don’t have experience with this exact situation. What if we explore it together and see what emerges?”
This moment of authentic presence—letting go of the expert role—created space for collaborative exploration. Cleo began articulating not just the facts of her challenge but her emotional response to it. Sarah found herself asking questions she’d never considered. Together, they uncovered insights about Cleo’s leadership style and organisational dynamics that neither had anticipated.
For Sarah, this shift from “perfect mentor” to authentic presence initially felt uncomfortable but ultimately proved more fulfilling. For Cleo, seeing her mentor embrace uncertainty gave her permission to bring her whole self to the relationship rather than just his polished “ideal mentee” persona.
The outcome? Cleo successfully navigated her challenge using strategies that emerged from their collaborative exploration, and Sarah discovered new dimensions of her own leadership philosophy.
Addressing Common Concerns
“This sounds nice, but we don’t have time for deep philosophical conversations.”
Authentic presence doesn’t require lengthy sessions or philosophical discussions. It’s about the quality of attention, not the quantity of time. A 20-minute conversation with genuine presence often produces more value than an hour of surface-level advice exchange.
“What if this gets too personal or crosses professional boundaries?”
Authentic presence operates within appropriate professional boundaries. It’s about bringing your whole self to professional relationships, not sharing inappropriate personal details. The focus remains on growth, development, and work-related challenges—but with deeper engagement and genuine curiosity.
“I’m supposed to be the expert. Won’t admitting uncertainty undermine my credibility?”
Research consistently shows that leaders who demonstrate appropriate vulnerability are perceived as more trustworthy and effective. Admitting the limits of your experience while maintaining your areas of genuine expertise actually enhances credibility.
Getting Started: Three Practical Steps
1. Start with Awareness
Begin noticing when you slip into “mentorship performance mode.” Are you giving advice because you genuinely have valuable insight, or because you feel expected to have answers? Are you asking questions out of real curiosity, or to fulfil your role as a good mentee? This awareness alone creates space for more authentic engagement.
2. Practice Arriving
Before mentoring sessions, invest 5-10 minutes in genuinely arriving. Feel your physical connection to your chair or the ground beneath your feet. Take several complete breaths. Consciously set aside your agenda and preconceptions. Ask yourself: “What does this person actually need from me today?”
3. Ask Generative Questions
Move beyond problem-solving questions to those that invite genuine exploration:
- Instead of “What solutions have you considered?” try “What aspect of this challenge feels most alive or energising to you?”
- Rather than “What’s your action plan?” ask “What wants to emerge from this situation?”
- Replace “How can I help?” with “What are you noticing about yourself as you navigate this?”
The Ripple Effect: Beyond Individual Relationships
When mentors and mentees develop authentic presence, the benefits extend far beyond their individual relationship. They develop capacity for deeper engagement in all professional interactions—with teams, clients, and leadership. Organisations with cultures that support authentic presence in developmental relationships often see increased innovation, higher engagement, and more effective leadership at all levels.
Moving Forward: Your Next Step
Authentic presence isn’t a destination but an ongoing practice. Each mentoring conversation becomes an opportunity to deepen this capacity. The rewards—transformative insights, meaningful connections, and sustained growth—make this journey not just worthwhile but essential for mentorship that genuinely transforms careers and lives.
Start where you are. Notice your patterns. Practice arriving fully to your next mentoring conversation. See what emerges when you bring your authentic presence to the relationship.
The person you’re mentoring—and your own development—will thank you for it.
Ready to take the next step in your mentoring journey? Join OneUpOneDown today.
GET GROWING THROUGH MENTORSHIP
Join our monthly newsletter to get updated on mentorship opportunities and actionable insights to learn and grow through relationships.
Follow OneUpOneDown on Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter and Instagram to stay tuned with the latest news.